今トライナリーでずっと言われていることは、自分で調べて吟味し、自分で考えるということなのだと思います。(この設問の場合、私はあまり迷わなかったけど。)思考実験は極めて限定された条件下で判断しますが、現実ではほぼ100%それ以外の要素が入ってくるので、判断は簡単に覆ります。(ゆえに現実における判断材料としては根拠がかなり脆弱。)ではこのような実験の意義は何かというと、やはり様々な角度から物事を捉え、考えるという訓練の意味があるのではないでしょうか。とはいえ、知識があっても経験がなければできないこともあり、千羽鶴ちゃんや原初のつばめに足りないのはそこではないかと。
I believe what Trinary has been telling us is that we need to research by ourselves and think with our own heads. (In case of this question, I didn't hesitate much to answer though.) Thought experiment is supposed to decide under.extremely limited condition, but other conditions would come along in reality by 100% of possibility, so the decision can be easily overturned. (Therefore, to use it as a factor for decision in reality is groundless and quite weak.) Then what is the meaning of such thought experiments? I consider it is a training to watch things multidirectionally and think. However, there are things you can't do without experience, even if you have knowledge: I suppose that is what Chiharu and Original Tsubame lack.
![]() |
Original Tsubame: Whether you press the "attack" button, please decide yourself. |
名場面とはちょっと違うけど、秘密の扉を覗いてしまった時のカレンとの会話。「実際私がでぶーんってしちゃったら、ごめんねって言いますよね?」自分を棚にあげて一番上以外なんか選べないです、私は。(そしてこの後更迭されるカレン…名前を教えてくれてありがとう。)
This might not be suitable for impressive scenes, but I like this conversation with Karen when I sneaked into her secret door. "If I get fat, you'd tell me that I'm not your type, wouldn't you?" I can't choose except first one while shutting my eyes for myself. (And Karen was switched after this...thank you for telling me your name.)
![]() |
Answer: --No, I wouldn't! --N, no, I wouldn't! --...I'm sorry. |